Hi there,
In fact, you'd want to avoid a tunnel down from "remote office", although what are the risks:
1 -- "Remote Office" ISP line/hardware down/bricked.
2 -- OPNsense cluster down.
3 -- local Layer2 devices (switches etc) down.
4 -- "Home Office" unreachable.
In the occurrence of either 1, 2, 3 (and/or); there won't be any connectivity to anything at all from "Remote Office" anyways.
Hence, how many times a year is the "Home Office" unreachable?
If I'd be in your shoes, I'd raise a few questions and would try to get their real answers:
-- do we really "need" all the "remote office" traffic to "break out" at "home office" ? Wouldn't internal resources be enough I.E: 10.0.0.0/8
-- Connectivity behind a FW typically means Layer3, does it make sense to cross a tunnel to get the needed Layer3 remote endpoints setup (DHCP over IPsec)?
-- what is the "remote office" sustained bandwidth need at an average ?
-- what about adding a cheap LTE 4G/5G local break out at "remote office" ?
I would go for a backup "line" with LTE 4G/5G if sustainable.
Also, is IPsec a compliance tied item? WireGuard tunnels would come up extremely fast from which ever source IP coming from your "Remote Office".
Hope this helps a bit.
Cheers
In fact, you'd want to avoid a tunnel down from "remote office", although what are the risks:
1 -- "Remote Office" ISP line/hardware down/bricked.
2 -- OPNsense cluster down.
3 -- local Layer2 devices (switches etc) down.
4 -- "Home Office" unreachable.
In the occurrence of either 1, 2, 3 (and/or); there won't be any connectivity to anything at all from "Remote Office" anyways.
Hence, how many times a year is the "Home Office" unreachable?
If I'd be in your shoes, I'd raise a few questions and would try to get their real answers:
-- do we really "need" all the "remote office" traffic to "break out" at "home office" ? Wouldn't internal resources be enough I.E: 10.0.0.0/8
-- Connectivity behind a FW typically means Layer3, does it make sense to cross a tunnel to get the needed Layer3 remote endpoints setup (DHCP over IPsec)?
-- what is the "remote office" sustained bandwidth need at an average ?
-- what about adding a cheap LTE 4G/5G local break out at "remote office" ?
I would go for a backup "line" with LTE 4G/5G if sustainable.
Also, is IPsec a compliance tied item? WireGuard tunnels would come up extremely fast from which ever source IP coming from your "Remote Office".
Hope this helps a bit.
Cheers
"