Access between two interfaces

[pickone]

Hi!

I don't understand something, being a 5 days newbie to OPNSense, maybe someone can explain to me.

Let's say that I have a minipc with two lan interfaces (lan1, lan2), we don't talk about wan, only lans.
One cable between my computer and LAN1 plug of the minipc...

minipc interfaces:
LAN1 192.168.10.1
LAN2 192.168.20.1

My computer's IP 192.168.10.2.
From my computer, I can access the router's GUI and change all the settings.
If I ping 192.168.10.1 it is working.
There is any solution to access/ping 192.168.20.1 from my computer as well or I don't understand how the thinks are working with OPNSense?
If there is any solution, please share to me. In rules, I passed everything to everything for both interfaces, in the firewall rules:     

Code: [Select]

IPv4 * * * * * * * Default allow LAN to any rule
Thank you in advance!

[netnut]

There is any solution to access/ping 192.168.20.1 from my computer as well or I don't understand how the thinks are working with OPNSense?

Ping interfaces is default network functionality, nothing OPNsense special:

- What is the status of the LAN2 interface when you try to ping it ? In Interfaces: Overview, what is the "Status" of LAN2: Red or Green ?

- If it's Red, is LAN2 connected to some network device that's powered on Switch / PC ?

[pickone]

There is any solution to access/ping 192.168.20.1 from my computer as well or I don't understand how the thinks are working with OPNSense?

Ping interfaces is default network functionality, nothing OPNsense special:

- What is the status of the LAN2 interface when you try to ping it ? In Interfaces: Overview, what is the "Status" of LAN2: Red or Green ?

- If it's Red, is LAN2 connected to some network device that's powered on Switch / PC ?

It is Red because I did not inserted any cable in LAN2. I thought that I can ping the interface

[netnut]

It is Red because I did not inserted any cable in LAN2. I thought that I can ping the interface

If a physical ethernet interface isn't _actively_ connected to "the network" it isn't working (No Carrier) so there's no reason to send packets to it, hence an ICMP ping fails.

There're lot of use cases where you might want a physical interface to be "Up" even without a physical connection, but your case is standard ethernet behaviour.

[pickone]

Alright, now I understand how it is working...
I need another device which should be in LAN2, then transmit a ping to this. I thought that because the interface have an IP, I can ping it as well.

Thank you for the explication.

[netnut]

I need another device which is in the LAN2, that can be transmited a ping action. I thought that because the interface have an IP, I can ping it as well.

No, you need the interface you're trying to ping, LAN2 in your case to be UP. The only way to get that LAN2 interface UP is connecting it to some other Ethernet device (or do some magic in /etc/rc.conf, but that's another story).

[pickone]

Last question, just to be sure :-D

After I add something to LAN2 and it will be green. I can ping even the interface 192.168.20.1? Or just the devices connected to LAN2? I am thinking to add a cable between LAN2 and LAN3 

[netnut]

After I add something to LAN2 and it will be green. I can ping even the interface 192.168.20.1? Or just the devices connected to LAN2? I am thinking to add a cable between LAN2 and LAN3 

Both, if your firewall rules will allow it (which should by default from LAN).

[pickone]

After I add something to LAN2 and it will be green. I can ping even the interface 192.168.20.1? Or just the devices connected to LAN2? I am thinking to add a cable between LAN2 and LAN3 

Both, if your firewall rules will allow it (which should by default from LAN).

Alright, thank you for the info.
Cheers

[pickone]

It is kinda strange...
I made LAN2 and LAN3 as green, then all the interfaces rules like this one:

      IPv4 *    *    *    *    *    *    *       Default allow LAN to any rule

But still I can't ping the interface... 

I can ping them all (LAN1, LAN2, LAN3), from inside the router, at Interfaces > Diagnostics > Ping... But not from my computer. From my computer, only LAN1 can get ping

[hushcoden]

My appliance has got 3x LAN ports with LAN1 (192.168.0.1) being the main one and with my laptop (IP address of 192.168.0.3) I'm able to ping the other two interfaces LAN2 and LAN3 (being on 192.168.10.1 and 192.168.20.1 respectively) regardless if I've got a device attached to them, e.g. I can ping LAN2 and LAN3 also if they are NOT up (i.e. no carrier / red cross icon).

I don't have the 'allow all' rule on any of the LAN interfaces, and for the ping I just added a rule in 'Floating' as

Code: [Select]

IPv4 ICMP * * * * * * 3 Allow ICMP echo request messages