Wireguard Roadwarrior setup not working (unable to complete handshake)

[JRC]

The client is not able to finish the handshake and I cannot work out why.

I followed the instruction here: https://docs.opnsense.org/manual/how-tos/wireguard-client.html and I have double and triple checked my settings and they match these settings, but I am unable to connect from any client, I am getting errors about the handshake not completing.

At this point I am at a loss as to what to do to get this working. I am not entirely sure what I need to post here to help work this out.

The interface I created in step 4(a) is called "Wireguard"

Outbound NAT Rule:

Code: [Select]

WAN Wireguard net * * * Interface address * NO Wireguard NAT Rule

WAN Rule:

Code: [Select]

  IPv4 UDP * * WAN address 51820 * * Open Wireguard Port
Wirguard Interface FW Rule:

Code: [Select]

    IPv4 * Wireguard net * * * * * Allow Traffic from Wireguard Clients
Normalization Rule:

Code: [Select]

WireGuard (Group), Wireguard any any Wireguard MSS Clamping IPv4
OpnSense V24.1.4


Any suggestions?


Also, some notes in the documentation:

• The numbering referenced in the article is wrong. When the instruction reference step 5(a) it actually means 4(a) (I think), this made parsing it pretty difficult.
• It would be nice if there were some more information about the keys and how to use them and/or how they relate to each other. Step 2 just tells you to insert a public key, and to go to step 7 (doesn't exist) in order to get info on how to generate said key.
• Step 5a tells you to use the interface Wireguard (Group) instead of the interface you created in step 4(a). Is this correct? (I tried both, but things still don't work)

[Bob.Dig]

Do you have a public IPv4-address in the first place? If so, log that firewall rule on your WAN and see, if it gets any hits from you.

[JRC]

I do have a public IPV4, and the firewall logs where not showing anything from my test setup (hotspot off my phone, also had a public IPV4).

When I tried to access my other services, I could see the traffic flowing (I was filtering by source IP), but when I tried to connect to the VPN I saw nothing.

It's possible that my cell provider is blocking VPN traffic, but I think this is very unlikely (Andoid phone on GoogleFi).

[JRC]

Eh, I gave up on this, and just spun up a VM with openVPN on it, and did a port forward. I'll use Firewall rules to control which VLAN/Service/Servers remote clients can and cannot get to.