[Solved] Sonos on VLANS

[marjohn56]

It works better than PIMD 


Sent you the plugin link via pm.

[lambrusco]

Hey marjohn56, may I have the plugin too?
Thanks!

[marjohn56]

PM  on the way...

[lambrusco]

Thanks a lot Marjohn, It works flawless with mDNS (used for AirPlay) but it has some issues with SSDP, here is my scenario:
Network 1: DLNA control point (iPhone Naim app)
Network 2: DLNA media server (QNAP NAS) + DLNA media renderer (Naim streamer
Configured relay to IP 239.255.255.250 for the 1900 UDP port.

Whenever I open the control point application from network 1 I can't see the media server.
If I restart the media server while I'm in the discovery screen of the control point I can see and select the Media Server.
If I close the app and reopen it the media server is gone.
So basically it seems that if the control point is running and the media server send the broadcast message at startup the frames got relayed, otherwise no. Please note that if I keep the control point app on the same network this does not happen and it always shows the Media Server.

Till now I tried to change the TTL flag and also enabled/disabled IGMP snooping, but nothing changes.
Do you have any advice on how can I debug this issue?

Many thanks for your work.

[marjohn56]

Sounds like the media server stops sending once it's got an ack from the control point. @bertofurth may have an idea, he's done some deep discovery work with the daemon.

[Gheek]

Hello everyone!
Thanks for your work this sounds amazing.
I am struggling for days to get different services IPTV, Sonos, Phillips etc running.

I would really like to test and give feedback as well. Could you send it to me to?

Best regards

[marjohn56]

See https://forum.opnsense.org/index.php?topic=15910.msg72858#msg72858

[lambrusco]

Sounds like the media server stops sending once it's got an ack from the control point.

I will try to debug once I get back home (this weekend) but it seems strange that he stops sending when he receive the ACK as this don't happens when both are connected under the same network.

Maybe @bertofurth has some suggestions on how to debug it.

Please let me know if you want to continue this discussion on the new thread.

Thanks a lot.

[marjohn56]

Network 1: DLNA control point (iPhone Naim app)
Network 2: DLNA media server (QNAP NAS) + DLNA media renderer (Naim streamer
Configured relay to IP 239.255.255.250 for the 1900 UDP port.

Re-reading this those settings are exactly the same as I use for my Sky receiver and app. It works perfectly and I have no issues, it was the reason I went with udpbroadcastrelay to start with as it worked so well. All I can suggest at this point is to do some packet sniffing on both VLANs, firstly when the media server is re-started, then again when it isn't and see what the difference is.