Traceroute / ICMP issue after 24.7.1 update

[newsense]

In the name of even more science :), how is the pf4 that was rebuilt today as well different from icmp2 ? Do we need to test that one too ?

[doktornotor]

Well, icmp2 has all the upstream FreeBSD patches from the bug linked in the thread.

[franco]

The pf4 is the one with all reverted.

[newsense]

Thanks guys, what I meant was the time stamp changed on the pf4 as it would have been rebuilt today, but that's ok. Running on icmp2 now, looks good so far.

Code Select Expand

kernel-24.7.1-pf4-amd64.txz 2024-08-14 12:39 33M
kernel-24.7.1-pf4-amd64.txz.sig 2024-08-14 12:39 1.3K
kernel-24.7.1-icmp2-amd64.txz 2024-08-14 15:20 33M
kernel-24.7.1-icmp2-amd64.txz.sig 2024-08-14 15:20 1.3K

[franco]

Ok, I've reverted on stable/24.7 now, the 24.7.1-pf4 is still there but holds the code that is going to be 24.7.2 next week

;)

[newsense]

Well, it's not official until we get people panicking about the revised SA and when it will be in OPNsense :D

[franco]

TBH, I'm still waiting for that video saying we ship incomplete code and that's why we are not being used.  8)

[newsense]

No worries, that was just the pilot episode. Spacetime will be bent again by the power of his mind - right after the next unaffiliated payment is received.

[franco]

How should we proceed? Ship the fixes or stay with the reverts?


Cheers,
Franco

[newsense]

GIven the security nature of it my vote is to ship. It is unlikely FreeBSD will make other changes if there aren't any other tests and the confirmed regressions have been addressed.

[Taunt9930]

Agree with newsense FWIW. Ship the fixes gets my vote.

[meyergru]

+1: Ship the fixes.

[staticznld]

Ship the fix!

[franco]

gotta love you all <3

[Patrick M. Hausen]

Upstream, upstream, upstream! Ship, ship, ship!  ;D