Traffic shaper stops working when adding multiple pppoe

[stevovo]

Hi,

I'm using version 15.7.17-amd64.

I did a clean install, set up my pppoe connection and put in a few traffic shaper rules. The rules work because I can see the one computer on the LAN speed drop as soon as I start doing speed tests on another computer.

The moment I add another pppoe connection, the traffic shaping no longer works.

I've restarted the firewall state rules and even rebooted but it only starts working again after removing the second pppoe

[franco]

Does the second PPPoE link come up ok? Is it usable? We've had reports of half-working scenarios, e.g. https://forum.opnsense.org/index.php?topic=1711.0

[stevovo]

Both ppp connections are from the same ISP. They both get a unique IP but under Status -> Gateways they have the same gateway?

I can still route connections out through either one using firewall rules though.

Could this be the issue?