Advice needed: Mini PC for my first OPNsense firewall

Started by sam1970, November 16, 2026, 08:18:21 PM

Previous topic - Next topic
Quote from: tangofan on November 17, 2026, 10:34:39 AMI would recommend the Amibios though, not their coreboot BIOS.
It's improved a lot but coreboot hasn't been bug-free.  Definitely AMI for full features, coreboot if you value the HAP disable function (to neuter the Intel ME).
N5105 | 8/250GB | 4xi226-V | Community

Quote from: sam1970 on November 16, 2026, 11:09:48 PMThanks for the advice. Let me clarify my network setup.

My NAS and main PC have a direct 2.5GbE connection. Both also connect to Switch 1 (managed Netgear, 1GbE).

Switch 2, near my ISP router, connects Sonos, WiFi, IoT devices, TVs, etc.

Currently, both switches are connected by a long Ethernet cable. I'd remove that connection and connect them directly to OPNsense:

- Port 1: WAN (ISP router)
- Port 2: Switch 1 (homelab)
- Port 3: Switch 2 (WiFi/IoT)
- Port 4: Spare

My goal is to isolate the homelab (VLAN 10) from WiFi/IoT (VLAN 20). Gigabit speeds are sufficient.

I'd prefer an established brand such as Protectli and an N305 CPU for future Suricata experiments.
In your setup you actually do not need more than two ports. My Protectli VP2420 has four, but two are empty. You just group the two VLANs for homelab and WiFi/IoT onto one physical port and - since you have managed switches - you can split those VLANs on one switch into various access ports (and connect that second switch, if you want to).

Talking about WiFi: I am using two Ruckus R650 wireless access points (bought cheaply on eBay) in a mesh network. The nice thing about them is that they can handle VLANs, so I have put different SSIDs on different VLANs to keep all nice and separated.

Despite the fact that I only use two ports on my VP2420, I am happy that I have four, because I have configured one of them as a rescue port. In my current configuration the LAN port carries all my VLANs to my core switch (MikroTik CRS310) and all my devices connect to the router over one of the various VLANs. So that rescue port is a way for me to get into OPNsense directly via a network port, if something should go wrong with all those VLANs and I need direct network access to the router.

@tangofan

Thanks for sharing your experience with Zenarmor, especially the performance impact and RAM usage. That's very useful information. Since my switches are limited to 1Gbps, the reduced throughput wouldn't necessarily be a problem, but the memory consumption is worth considering.

I'm not yet convinced I need Suricata or Zenarmor running permanently. I'll probably start with basic OPNsense functionality and experiment with them later. I'll also be choosing AMI BIOS rather than coreboot.

@meyergru

Thanks for pointing out the bridging issue. To clarify, I don't intend to bridge the two LAN interfaces. I would disconnect the cable between the switches and connect each switch to a separate routed OPNsense interface, with its own subnet and firewall rules. VLAN tagging would only be used where needed.

@OPNenthu and @yourfriendarmando

You make a good point about having a spare management port. Being able to access OPNsense directly if something goes wrong with the VLAN configuration is definitely useful.

I'm now leaning towards a device with at least four built-in Intel NICs rather than adding an expansion card.

Thanks everyone for the helpful advice and real-world experiences!

Hi everyone,

Thanks again for all the advice. I've been in contact with Protectli Europe, and they actually recommend the VP4651 for my 24/7 OPNsense firewall.

Their main reasons are the Core i5 processor, dual-channel RAM support, six built-in Intel NICs and completely fanless operation. They consider it a more reliable long-term solution than expanding the N305-based VP3230 with an additional NIC and cooling fan.

I'm now comparing these two models:

Hardware comparison


SpecificationVP2430eVP4651
CPUIntel N150Intel i5-10310U
Generation20252020
Cores / Threads4 / 44 / 8
Base clockNot specified1.7 GHz
Max. turbo3.6 GHz4.4 GHz
CPU power rating6 W15 W
Ethernet4x Intel i226-V6x Intel i226-V
RAMDDR5-4800DDR4-2666
RAM slots12 (dual-channel)
NVMe 228011
CoolingFanlessFanless
Firmware choiceAMI BIOSAMI BIOS
VESA mountIncludedIncluded
Barebone incl. VAT€458.59€700.59

Product links:
https://eu.protectli.com/product/vp2430e/
https://eu.protectli.com/product/vp4651/

RAM costs and total prices

I already own an 8 GB Transcend DDR4-2666 SO-DIMM (TS1GSH64V6B). For the VP4651, I'm considering adding an 8 GB Samsung M471A1K43DB1-CTD for approximately €60.

Protectli confirmed that the specifications match, but the combination hasn't been officially validated, so stability and dual-channel operation aren't guaranteed.

DDR5 prices are currently much higher. Here is my comparison using indicative retail prices:


ConfigurationVP2430eVP4651
8 GB RAM€179€0 (already owned)
Total with 8 GB€637.59€700.59
16 GB RAM€303€60 (additional 8 GB)
Total with 16 GB€761.59€760.59

These totals include VAT but exclude any additional shipping costs. I'll reuse one of my existing WD Red SN700 NVMe drives.

Interestingly, both systems would cost almost exactly the same with 16 GB RAM.

My main concern is whether the older Core i5-10310U is worth choosing over the newer, more energy-efficient N150, especially for continuous 24/7 operation.

I haven't decided whether I'll run Suricata or Zenarmor permanently. For normal routing, VLANs, WireGuard and firewall rules, I understand that either CPU should be sufficient.

Which of these two Protectli models would you choose for a home network and homelab?

I'm particularly interested in long-term reliability, idle power consumption and whether the additional CPU performance and dual-channel RAM of the VP4651 offer a meaningful advantage.

Thanks again for your experiences and advice!

deleted. posted by mistake...

Quote from: sam1970 on November 17, 2026, 05:36:28 PMMy main concern is whether the older Core i5-10310U is worth choosing over the newer, more energy-efficient N150, especially for continuous 24/7 operation.

I haven't decided whether I'll run Suricata or Zenarmor permanently. For normal routing, VLANs, WireGuard and firewall rules, I understand that either CPU should be sufficient.

Which of these two Protectli models would you choose for a home network and homelab?

I'm particularly interested in long-term reliability, idle power consumption and whether the additional CPU performance and dual-channel RAM of the VP4651 offer a meaningful advantage.

Thanks again for your experiences and advice!
Between those two models you list I would probably go for the VP2430e. According to https://www.cpubenchmark.net/compare/3698vs6304/Intel-i5-10310U-vs-Intel-N150 the i5 is about 12% faster than the N150 both in the single-thread and multi-thread Passmark benchmarks. The question then is: Is this going to make a difference?

Things to consider:
- My J6412 CPU already managed ca. 1.1Gbps with Zenarmor enabled. Since the N150 is about 39% faster in single-thread mode ( https://www.cpubenchmark.net/compare/6304vs4474/Intel-N150-vs-Intel-Celeron-J6412 ), it should reach about 1.5 Gbps. (Back-of-the-envelopt calculation). That is not enough to saturate two switches on the VP2430e, but the VP4651 likely won't saturate them either (even when considering the improved memory architecture). So for Zenarmor it won't make a significant difference.

- I know (by now) that Suricata is multi-threaded, but what the bandwidth for a home network setup would be, I have no idea. I have read though Suricata the really benefits from the better bandwidth of a multi-channel memory architecture. So Suricata should provide for a much higher bandwidth than Zenarmor (say 2x, if you dedicate two CPU cores to it), even before considering the improved memory architecture. At 2x you are already saturating two switches, so do you need more?

- The thoughts above are for your current setup, where each switch has 1G NICs and is connected to a separate port on the router. Perhaps in the future you'd like a faster home network and will upgrade those to 2.5G or 10G? If that is a future consideration, that might change the equation.

- Another question is what traffic you actually want to track with Zenarmor or Suricata? (I say "or", because I don't think "and" really is an option here, the CPU power just isn't there.) In Zenarmor you're supposed to specify LAN interfaces (ideally physical ones) for monitoring. In your case you might track the Wifi, but exclude the homelab, because that's where your servers and your trusted devices reside. Which would mean that a much smaller percentage of your overall network traffic is subject to tracking.

As I previously said, I'm running a Protectli unit with a J6412 CPU and it works well enough. And while it wasn't powerful enough for Zenarmor, it likely would be doing much better with Suricata due to the multithreaded architecture, but at this point I chose to forego IDS/IPS as a security mechanism and rely on IP and domain based blocklists. Of course there are no kids in my household, so I don't need any sophisticated mechanism for content blocking.

If I was sure that I really needed the CPU Horsepower, I would probably get the VP6670 with an i7-1255U. But that's a different price range and when I had similar considerations two years ago, in the end I opted for the J6412, because at the time it was a decent balance between price and performance. Today I would likely opt for the N150 or the i7-1255U.

Just some more food for thought to complicate your decision further. ;)

@tangofan

Thanks again for your detailed advice. I'm leaning towards the VP2430e as well.

Regarding power consumption, electricity currently costs around €0.37/kWh here in Belgium, while a more typical price is €0.27/kWh. Even if the difference in consumption between the two systems amounted to €30 per year at the higher rate, I have solar panels, so I'd estimate my effective additional cost at roughly €15 per year.

That's negligible to me. I think power efficiency sometimes gets more attention than it deserves when comparing devices in this category. Reliability and performance matter more to me.

I have one remaining question, and I'd appreciate your experience and that of the other forum members.

Would you buy the VP2430e with 8 GB or 16 GB RAM?

I have no experience with Zenarmor, so I genuinely don't know whether it would provide a meaningful security benefit for my home network. You mentioned that you eventually stopped using IDS/IPS and now rely on IP and domain blocklists instead.

For someone with my network setup, is Zenarmor actually worth running permanently, or are properly configured firewall rules and blocklists generally sufficient?

If Zenarmor offers little practical benefit in my situation, I'd rather buy the VP2430e with 8 GB RAM and keep the setup simple. If the additional memory makes a meaningful difference, I'm willing to invest in 16 GB.

I'd be interested in hearing what you and the other members would choose based on your experience.

Quote from: sam1970 on <strong>Today</strong> at 10:37:06 AMWould you buy the VP2430e with 8 GB or 16 GB RAM?

I have no experience with Zenarmor, so I genuinely don't know whether it would provide a meaningful security benefit for my home network. You mentioned that you eventually stopped using IDS/IPS and now rely on IP and domain blocklists instead.

For someone with my network setup, is Zenarmor actually worth running permanently, or are properly configured firewall rules and blocklists generally sufficient?

If Zenarmor offers little practical benefit in my situation, I'd rather buy the VP2430e with 8 GB RAM and keep the setup simple. If the additional memory makes a meaningful difference, I'm willing to invest in 16 GB.

I remember that with Zenarmor enabled, I was using 7+GB of RAM. That was running OPnsense on ZFS (which has its own filesystem cache called "Adaptive Replacement Cache" or "ARC") with several plugins like os-crowdsec (blocklists), os-q-feeds-connector (IP- and DNS blocklists), os-tailscale and a few smaller ones. Under no circumstances would I forego ZFS and I strongly recommend that you also use ZFS, instead of UFS, as your file system. The option to take snapshots and rollback your configuration, if an update goes awry, is just too good to give up. At the moment I am using 1.2 GB of RAM and that is with both AdGuard and Unbound having blocklists configured (though Unbound is currently not in my active DNS chain and just "chilling").

So the RAM usage of Zenarmor (and presumably of Suricata as well) is enormous and I would not be comfortable with 8GB RAM, if I were to use either. That gets right to the question then, whether they will be useful. Zenarmor is designed to run on the LAN interface(s), not on the WAN interface, so its focus is on outgoing requests (though it may apply some filtering to responses as well, I don't know). What I liked about Zenarmor was the ability to finely tune, what kind of requests I wanted to block, e.g. I could block "VPN-providers" as a category, but then exempt perhaps a particular VPN-provider that I am using. For blocklists you would need a particular blocklist for that kind of request to do the same. For VPN provides such a blocklist ist available IIRC, but if you want to go specific on other kinds of requests (say for example "Torrent Servers") you'd have to find that blocklist or even make one yourself. BTW that configuration granularity is only available with a paid Zenarmor subscription (which I had for two years), the free version gives you significantly fewer screws to turn. Again, just my impression of Zenarmor, I really don't know much of anything about Suricata.

The question then is: Do you need that kind of granularity and flexibility for your blocking of client requests? Perhaps if you have children in your household, but then you'll need to be ready to paid 100 Euros per year or so for a home subscription. I decided that for me this granularity was only "nice to have", but you have to judge for yourself what your needs are. If you decide, that you want to give this a try, I would lean toward getting 16 GB of RAM, just to have some headroom. (In fact for my case - as I said in my previous post - I would even lean to the VP4651 with the i7, since I have a 2.5GB connection from OPNsense to my 10GB switch.) As an aside, in hindsight I am actually glad that I got rid of Zenarmor a few months ago. The company's policy re. "multi-threading", essentially "It will be available 'soon', but only on the highest business subscription tiers and everyone else will still get to use a single thread", was a major turn-off for me. Had they provided/promised that the home subscription tier would get a 2-thread or 4-thread cap (instead of the current 1-thread cap), I would have stayed with my paid home subscription.

If you really can't decide on the memory, I would spend that extra 130 Euros or so on 16GB of RAM just for the optionality. But that's how I roll.

BTW here is what I am currently using in terms of security:
- The built-in firewall (of course)
- Maxmind GeoIP (blocks incoming WAN requests that are assigned to geo locations that you want to block)
- Q-Feeds plugin (provides ip and dns blocking list). I actually have the paid "Plus" subscription
- Crowdsec plugin (also IP and DNS blocklists)
- Blocklists in Unbound/AdGuard (the latter being available as a plugin (I just started using AdGuard, so I mirrored my Unbound blocklists into AdGuard)

There is almost certainly some overlap between the blocklists from Crowdsec Q-Feeds and Unbound/Adguard, but I do not mind. Processing is plenty fast and memory consumption is not an issue at all.

Hope that helps.