Bug in wireguard ? Cant start more than 3 wireguard-servers.

[Layer8]

Hey,

i upgraded my homelab-sense to v22.1 last week. Today i added the fourth wireguard server (wg3) for a additional site2site connection.

I tried to add wg3 as interface but i failed at first, because the interface-assignement-page reported:

The following input errors were detected:

    Port vmx0 was assigned to 2 interfaces: OPT8 OPT11

vmx0 is the interface which is attached to my DSL-modem. I am using it to reach the webinterface of my DSL-modem and also as pppoe parent interface.

But now, vmx0 is also assigned to an interface which is actually assigned to wg0. If i open this wg0_WGServer1... called interface, wg0 is still assigned, but not in the assignment-overview.

Please take a look at the screenshot to see what i mean.

It was possible to workaround the above error-msg, by klicking on the Add-New-Interface button and then directly clicking on the new assigned interface to edit it instead of klicking the save button.

[mimugmail]

So, wg0 is badly assigned? What happens when you change this?

[Layer8]

Right now, wg0 is still assigned to the wg0_WGServer1-interface "in the background" (as you can see on the screenshot) and its connected with a other site right now.

I am afraid to assigne a other adapter (a VLAN-Adapter for example) to wg0_WGServer1..., because wg0 is notlonger listed in the dropdown menu.

[Layer8]

OK, thats not true what i said. The site which is connected to wg0 was no longer reachable.


I removed the fourth wireguard-instance from the wireguard local section and wg0 started to work immediately after that. wg0 is also available again in the dropdown menu and wg0 is also assigned to wg0_WGServer1...-Interface in the interface-overview again.

So, looks like there is a bug or limitation in wireguard or opnsense. Its not possible to start four or more wireguard servers.

Can one confirm that?

[mimugmail]

Cant confirm since we raised it from 19 to unlimited due to report that 19 is not enough
Maybe you interface names are too long? Something else in there? Hard to say from remote

[Layer8]

Is there a limitation in length of interface names?

wg0 is 37 chars long
wg1 is 38 chars long
wg2 is 36 chars long

wg3 was also 38chars long.

Cant tests at the moment because some people will be mad if cut off services right now. Maybe tomorrow or at the weekend.

[dmmincrjr]

I'm not trying to hijack a thread but I posted something similar in the VPN forum.

https://forum.opnsense.org/index.php?topic=26797.0

I only received 1 response from someone else who had the same issue. I've continued to try and troubleshoot without any luck. I resolved the package misconfigured in plugins manager hoping that was the problem but no luck. It was after upgrading from 21.7.8 to 22.1 I encountered the problem and reinstalled 21.7.8 with the same configuration and it now works but would like to upgrade.

I'm just posting this in case these are somehow related and will continue to watch this thread.

[mimugmail]

I have no idea about the limitation, but when I'm in the UI I can't imagine where such a long name is correctly displayed. I'd say best to keep it under 32

[Layer8]

I cant see any problems with long interface-names. All long interface names are displayed correctly in the menu bar, in drop down menus if they are wide enough. And everything is working fine with long interface names.

Remember: wg0, wg1 and wg2 are working fine with interface names longer than 32chars.


Only if i add wg3, things start to get strange:

- wg0 stopped working
- suddenly, vmx0 was assigned for the interface, which was wg0 before i added wg3. what's that got to do with it?
- oh and i forgot to say: neither wg0, nor wg3 was displayed under "List Configuration" or "Handshake" section in wireguard interface.

[mimugmail]

Go to UI and do a:

cat /usr/local/etc/wireguard/wg0.conf

And

/usr/local/etc/rc.d/wireguard restart

When you added the 4th service. Maybe wg0 is not available anymore because it doesn't start cause of a config error or overlapping in 4th instance. Just guessing ..

Also, what is the exact reason why you assign those wg interfaces?

[Layer8]

I will test this at the weekend.

I think its easier to keep the overview of firewall rulesets if i can set it per site/wg-interface. Its messy if dozens of rules of different sites are defined on one wg-interface.

Also, its easier to cut off a site temporarily by just disabling a wg-interface.

[zitlo]

Hello @all

I just updated two boxes to OPNsense 22.1-amd64 and I cant start my wireguard services anymore.

I reinstalled wireguard packages and I rebooted OPNsense twice, no success.
Its difficult right now to get logs, because I do not have SSH access right now...

[Layer8]

I think i found the reason for this problem and basically it was my fault so its not absolutely a bug, but maybe a not working or net yet implemented interception of misconfiguration.

This error happens, when a wg-instance is configured with an subnetaddress or subnetrange, which overlaps with a subnetaddress or subnetrange of a endpoint - but only if this endpoint is peered with a wg-intance.

I came up with this problem because i did cat /usr/local/etc/wireguard/wg*.conf for all configured wg-interfaces and compared the configuration. I found a overlap between tunnel address of wg0 and a endpoint, which i peered with wg3. This led into a crash of wg0  (which was replaced with vmx0 in the interface-assignement overview) and into a not starting wg3 i think.


So, two suggestions:

1. It would be nice to see a "running config" tab in wireguard, which lists all wg#.conf-igurations in one view. This would give a better overview for debugging.

2. It would be nice if you could add interception of those kind of misconfigurations.

[zitlo]

Hey Layer8,

thank you for this solution, but it didnt solved my problem. I cant start wireguard service.

I moved all configurations /usr/local/etc/wireguard/wg*.conf and wireguard is still not starting anymore.

How I can debug this? Where to look for logs?

[mimugmail]

/usr/local/etc/rc.d/wireguard restart