Quote from: nero355 on October 02, 2026, 09:12:07 PMDefinitely weird : You need to Bridge that Modem/Router from your ISP and use it as a pure Modem that way on the WAN of your OPNsense :)
What you have know is the same 192.168.1.0/24 subnet at two places and that can't work properly because your OPNsense did not know where the traffic should go : WAN or LAN ?!
I definitely agree with you that this is not the setup you would want to have, though, apart from this issue, it has been working like a charm. I'm keeping the modem there to at least have some sort of protection from my own mistakes. I might start looking at a separate appliance to run OPNsense on - for now I'm gonna enjoy that it's functioning again. Thanks for your replies!
(Somewhat of a) solution to this issue:
In case you have a similar setup, don't define your OPNsense LAN interface as gateway on hardware within the same subnet.
"