I feel really dumb, but the solution was surprisingly simple. All I had to do was add https:// to the front. I assumed Chrome did that automatically. Thanks so much to both of you for pointing me in the right direction!
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Show posts Menu(/usr/obj/usr/ports/www/lighttpd/work/lighttpd-1.4.82/src/mod_openssl.c.4647) SSL: addr:192.168.10.17 ssl_err:1 error:0A00009C:SSL routines::http request(/usr/obj/usr/ports/www/lighttpd/work/lighttpd-1.4.82/src/server.c.1271) [note] graceful shutdown started
(/usr/obj/usr/ports/www/lighttpd/work/lighttpd-1.4.82/src/server.c.2372) server stopped by UID = 0 PID = 93511
(/usr/obj/usr/ports/www/lighttpd/work/lighttpd-1.4.82/src/server.c.1971) server started (lighttpd/1.4.82)
(/usr/obj/usr/ports/www/lighttpd/work/lighttpd-1.4.82/src/h1.c.441) unexpected TLS ClientHello on clear port (192.168.10.17)