1
23.7 Legacy Series / Re: Local host game server lan connetion issues
« on: November 03, 2023, 10:16:50 am »
I set opnsense up on some old hardware i had laying about as a back up for pfsense so that for what ever reason I could just unplug then swap boxes then be up and running in minutes. Pluged it in to test internet connection and some other bits and I havent swaped back other than for some testing
I ended up doing a fresh vanilla install of pfsense as my results varied quite a bit to opnsense.
Results are strange and I cant explain them but the results are repeatable
1) Ping is lower on opnsense by a noticable ammount
2) upload download speed remain the same
3) on pfsense the 7days server even with portforward and all the correct rules refused to be visable from the outside world and I lost hours trying to get that working. Seems I was not alone as many others reported the same and response seemed to be "It happens. Some steam servers work and some dont"
4) Ocasional stutters I was getting two to three times daily for sub 30 seconds have gone. I blamed that on isp but seems i was wrong
So far Im very happy with what im seeing especialy when I realised I was comparing fresh install of pfsense against opnsense and only realised after that ids and ips were turned on with opnsense.
Bad testing on my part but impressed with the results especialy when you consider my current opnsense is running on lower spec hardware.
Main thing is the wife and kids havent been shouting at me because whatsapp/snapchat have stoped working, wifes laptop is still doing its thing with video calls and ip phone so I will give it a little longer but looks to me like im here to stay.
I ended up doing a fresh vanilla install of pfsense as my results varied quite a bit to opnsense.
Results are strange and I cant explain them but the results are repeatable
1) Ping is lower on opnsense by a noticable ammount
2) upload download speed remain the same
3) on pfsense the 7days server even with portforward and all the correct rules refused to be visable from the outside world and I lost hours trying to get that working. Seems I was not alone as many others reported the same and response seemed to be "It happens. Some steam servers work and some dont"
4) Ocasional stutters I was getting two to three times daily for sub 30 seconds have gone. I blamed that on isp but seems i was wrong
So far Im very happy with what im seeing especialy when I realised I was comparing fresh install of pfsense against opnsense and only realised after that ids and ips were turned on with opnsense.
Bad testing on my part but impressed with the results especialy when you consider my current opnsense is running on lower spec hardware.
Main thing is the wife and kids havent been shouting at me because whatsapp/snapchat have stoped working, wifes laptop is still doing its thing with video calls and ip phone so I will give it a little longer but looks to me like im here to stay.