Figured it out!
I added the rdr rule in the wrong place, should be on NAT, PortForward
Source LAN net -> port * -> Destination "ALIAS" -> port 80 & 443 -> gateway *
And for the unrestricted IPs on LAN:
Source ADMIN alias -> port * -> Destination * -> port * -> gateway *
I added the rdr rule in the wrong place, should be on NAT, PortForward
Source LAN net -> port * -> Destination "ALIAS" -> port 80 & 443 -> gateway *
And for the unrestricted IPs on LAN:
Source ADMIN alias -> port * -> Destination * -> port * -> gateway *