Quote from: franco on Today at 02:45:54 PMOkay, fair.
Cheers,
Franco
Quote from: falkt on Today at 04:28:34 PMIch habe zum Test einfach mal die Paketfilterung ganz abgeschaltet.
Quote from: franco on Today at 03:40:11 PMBecause they are purely random and wrong.Random yes, but wrong? I'm not aware of any RFCs requiring IAIDs to have semantic meaning or structure. Any 32-bit unsigned integer is fine.
Quote from: franco on Today at 03:40:11 PMI don't mind another look or proposal.Just keep in mind that changing IAIDs can break existing setups. If DHCPv6 static bindings are configured on the upstream DHCPv6 server, an IAID change can cause a mismatch. I recently had that issue in the real world when OpenWrt changed their IAID calculation logic.
Quote from: franco on Today at 03:40:11 PMBut that only matters for IAID+DUID pairs when the multi-WAN connections are going to the exact same server.Which is not that uncommon, e. g. if you have two lines from the same ISP. Also, duplicate IAIDs (in the context of a given DUID and IA type) are a clear violation of the DHCPv6 specifications (RFC 9915), which I think we shouldn't do for no good reason.
Quote from: franco on Today at 03:40:11 PMI must admit the IAID changes are not for multi-WAN and we can test without them to go forward in 26.1.x regardless.I agree, it's a good idea to split these two issues.
Quote from: franco on Today at 03:40:11 PMLet me prepare a patch for that.I'll be happy to test it.
Quote from: franco on Today at 03:40:11 PMSure, I'll try to reword.Thanks a lot!
Quote from: franco on Today at 03:40:11 PMThere isn't a strong demand, but with multi-dhcp6 it's a possibility to leverage.I have no strong opinion about multiple DUIDs. While it doesn't seem intuitive (a DUID literally Uniquely IDentifies a Device, not a DHCPv6 client instance), I see no harm in it. And there might be use cases where it's actually helpful.
Quote from: demyers on Today at 04:04:16 PMAt the risk of going off topicPlease don't, this is a CFT.
Quote from: donee on Today at 02:34:50 PMI feel like a idiot.That sucks, but if you want help you need to post more information about your setup and settings applied ;)