Topics

1

General Discussion / PfSense tunnel to OpnSense ping work on one side

« on: February 22, 2019, 03:46:00 pm »

I create at tunne between a Pfsense and an OpnSense firewall


Network A <----> PfSense <----> OpnSense <----> Network B

Without adding any rules once the Tunnel was IP,
- Network B stations (behind OpenSense) can ping Network A stations

- But Network A stations cannot ping network B stations

Does OpnSense need extra rules we would not need to do on PfSense ?

JF

2

General Discussion / Simple NAT question NEW User to OpnSense

« on: February 21, 2019, 02:02:47 am »

Hello everyone,

I am new to OpnSense ( was using PfSense)

I am trying to do something that is usualy simple to do.

3 servers ----> OpnSense  (3 public IP)  ---->   Internet

I am trying to have those 3 servers on the internet with their own IP.
But After playing during a while with one server, it's always going out using the MAIN OpnSense IP.

I used the NAT section of the interface, tried NAT LAN, Nat WAN and it both case it didn't worked

When trying to use Nat 1 on on1, I specify the public IP I want to use, tell the NAT rule which server internally it need to be nated to

Question :
1- when creating the Nat rule, to O chose Lan or wan ? in both case I can specify what is the internal and external ip.
2- Virtual IP, do I have to use that ?

My test was simple, I curl ipinfo.io  and it gaved back the " main firewall" ip and not the one I created in the NAT rule

JF
Sorry for that newbie question LOL I played with so many brand of firewall and my ego too a hit :-)