I have just changed my main router to OPNSense on a new x86 device. After rebooting the opensense router, I can't get any response (ping/GUI) from the OPNSense device unless I reset the switch on my network core. Once the switch reboots, all is well (can access the router and WAN interface comes up)
My first thought was some MAC / ARP issue, but having power-cycled the whole core the problem persists.
I know this is odd - does anyone have any thoughts?
A re-install of OPNSense fixed the issue.
Just for completeness, the only explanation of which I can think is that the router and switch were struggling to auto-negotiate on the port and a reboot of the switch somehow fixed that. I recall a similar incident nearly twenty years ago when trying to get some PCs to connect to a Cisco switch. We just couldn't work out why certain machine didn't work until enabling portfast on the ports in question.
If anyone can think of any other possible reasons I remain curious....
Changing from the on-board NIC (Fujitsu S920) to another network port in the router seems to have resolved the issue. The router and switch indeed couldn't auto-negotiate. Perhaps a driver issue?
Quote from: kermitxyz on December 12, 2024, 11:59:16 PMChanging from the on-board NIC (Fujitsu S920) to another network port in the router seems to have resolved the issue. The router and switch indeed couldn't auto-negotiate. Perhaps a driver issue?
No help for you, but here's a similar weird one..
My Asustor NAS kept on dropping the connection (2.5 Gb/s) to the switch (cheap Chinese one). Rebooting either the switch of the NAS would bring it back up. It seemed to fail when I was hammering the NAS (backing up to the cloud at 2.5 Gb/s) so I suspected that something was overheating somewhere. I ordered a new switch. In the meantime one of the disks in the NAS failed with the "click of death", so I swapped it out. No NIC problems ever since so I have a spare switch!
Maybe the failing disk was drawing more current or sending spurious noise back over the SATA or power lines, who knows?
The Fujitsu S920 reportedly uses a Realtek NIC, so why wonder (see #6 (https://forum.opnsense.org/index.php?topic=42985.0))?